Nominations Queries 5

[modzilla]

Nominations have now closed, although a smaller number of additions will be possible during sign-ups. Thanks for all your nominations and for further answers, as I continue to have questions -


Chanur Series - C. J. Cherryh
Pyanfar Chanur & Crew of the 'Pride' (Chanur - Cherryh)
Who is covered by "the crew of the Pride", please? I have approved this before and I can't find notes about it, but would like to check if that includes named characters, or a set of unnamed characters, or both...?

Critical Role (Web Series)
Evandrin Alterra/Zerxus Ilerez & Elias (Critical Role)
Is this Elias the son of Zerxus or Elias de Corvo?

Crossover Fandom
Any of Class 1-A (BnHA) & Nara Shikako (DoS)
This is a large group, could I confirm who is wanted, please?

Discworld - Terry Pratchett
char: original entrepreneur character (discworld)
Could you help me out with a bit more information about what you were looking for, please? Is this, say, an Ankh-Morepork entrepreneur? (It doesn't have to be, I'm just trying to be clear on what you wanted here.)

Le Fantôme de l'Opéra | Phantom of the Opera & Related Fandoms
Do you have a preferred canon, please?

Green Men Series - K. J. Charles
Char: Beatrice Phan (Green Men Series)
I can find reference to a real person and to the character Syrena Phan. Could you confirm that Beatrice also appears as a character please?

Phineas and Ferb
Fireside Girls & Isabella Garcia-Shapiro (Phineas and Ferb)
Which Fireside Girls did you mean, please?



Please also let me know if there are stray or duplicated or mis-spelled characters or relationships!

Comments

[bronze_ribbons]

Hi! Regarding Green Men Series - K. J. Charles, the character is introduced in the chapter "Devils on Horseback":

Here one might find Dr. Silence, with his faithful hound by his side; Thomas Carnacki, always ready to tell a story (at length); the formidable Beatrice Phan, with her ever-friendly face, forgiving little and forgetting nothing; and on one memorable occasion Dr. Nikola himself, who held the room spellbound with his stories, fascinated even Miss Kay with his dark mesmeric gaze, and left with a rare compendium of Tibetan magic concealed under his coat.

Charles, KJ. The Secret Casebook of Simon Feximal (p. 126). KJC Books. Kindle Edition.

The character was indeed named after one of the women the book is dedicated to. Thanks!

[modzilla]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

Hi! Regarding Crossover Fandom: Any of Class 1-A (BnHA) & Nara Shikako (DoS), any student of Class 1-A would do. If that's too broad, Any Girl of Class 1-A (BnHA) & Nara Shikako (DoS) would work too!

[modzilla]

Thank you, the second would work.

[avandrathemarysueslayer]

Hi! Regarding Critical Role, Elias is Evandrin Alterra's biological son, and Zerxus becomes his stepfather when he marries Evandrin However, he sees Elias as his own child and loves him to bits, he doesn't care that they're not blood related. Elias has a very loving family!

[modzilla]

Thank you! We just weren't sure because there is another Elias in canon.

[(Anonymous)]

Hi! Regarding Chanur Series - C. J. Cherryh
Pyanfar Chanur & Crew of the 'Pride' (Chanur - Cherryh):

Pyanfar is the captain and the main crew is made up of her female relatives:

Haral Araun
Tirun Araun
Chur Anify
Geran Anify
Hilfy Chanur

The plot of the first book is about their stowaway alien (human) Tully, who eventually also becomes a crew member.

As time goes on the crew expands to include:

Khym Mahn (Pyanfar's husband)

Skkukuk | Vikktakkht (a low status person of an untrustworthy alien species foisted on Pyanfar - he's known by the first name while on her ship, by the second in his life afterwards).

The extra possibilities depend on when an author might want to set their story - pre-canon would just be the core crew. I thought just saying "crew" offered the most freedom, but am happy to be guided by you.

[modzilla]

Thanks! Would it work for it to mean any of:

Haral Araun
Tirun Araun
Chur Anify
Geran Anify
Hilfy Chanur
Tully
Khym Mahn
Skkukuk | Vikktakkht?

[(Anonymous)]

Yes, that’d be perfect - I think the automatic mental association for people will be the core crew (probably with Tully), but I did want to let anyone who wants to write the other two to have the chance!

[(Anonymous)]

Hi--for "Fireside Girls", I just meant any/all of Troop 46231. If you need specific names, I'll go for Gretchen, Holly, and Ginger.

[modzilla]

Thank you!

[(Anonymous)]

Wandering tags:
- Gawain/Essel (The Green Knight 2021) is in both The Green Knight (2021) where it belongs and Arthurian Mythology
- Hatake Kakashi & Nara Shikako & Uchiha Sasuke & Uzumaki Naruto (DoS) is in both Dreaming of Sunshine (Fanfic Disambiguation) where it belongs and Naruto
- Jinx/Silco (Arcane: League of Legends) is in both Arcane: League of Legends (Cartoon 2021) where it belongs and League of Legends

Misc things:
- Mantis/Thor (GOTG Movies) is under Guardians of the Galaxy (Movies) and Thor (Thor Movies)/Mantis (GotG Movies) is under Crossover Fandom - that's the same ship in the same continuity just in two different fandoms.
- likewise, you've got Wanda Maximoff/Pietro Maximoff (WandaVision) under WandaVision (TV) and Pietro Maximoff/Wanda Maximoff (CA Movies) under Captain America (Movies), though I guess that's a bit sketchier!

[(Anonymous)]

There's also a typo in Star Trek: Deep Space Nine: Original Klingon Character/Original Vulcan Characer (ST: DS9) - missing a T in the second "character".

[(Anonymous)]

Oh, and should "Wizard with unfair rep for being helpess/Warrior with unfair rep for being a meathead (M/M) (OW)" be helpless instead of helpess?

[modzilla]

Thanks for all these corrections, they're very helpful and I'll get to them soon! I think I'll leave the crossover ships in both places.

[(Anonymous)]

Hi!
I didn't submit any of the tags above, but I wanted to clarify one of my own nominations in advance, as I saw it's neither accepted nor rejected and I realised it may raise some questions. The fandom is Kate Beaton's Sherlock Holmes comic strips and characters I have in mind are various Watsons.
In nominated "Holmes & old Watson & new Watson" group, "old Watson" refers to character named dr.Watson in the second strip in a series, and "new Watson" to a character refered as "stupid Watson" in the same comic. In the "old Watson & Watsons" nomination, I meant the dr. Watson and creator's choice of stupid Watson, gay Watson and/or any OC Watsons. I nominated both relationships last minute before the nomination closed and looking at past queries and Guardian tv thread, I realised I should probably nom the relationships as:
Holmes & dr.Watson & stupid Watson (Holmes-Kate Beaton)
dr.Watson & Watsons[Any: stupid Watson gay Watson OCs] (Holmes-Kate Beaton)
or something similar. I'll be ok with any other phrasing too. I'm sorry if the nomination or the amount of word Watson in this comment caused you any problems or confusion and I hope you'll have a good day :)
(The fandom exists of 2 strips and both can be read here http://www.harkavagrant.com/index.php?id=210 and here http://www.harkavagrant.com/index.php?id=264 )

[(Anonymous)]

Thank you for accepting the noms <3

[modzilla]

Sorry for not seeing this earlier! Yes, the nomination looked fine, I was just wondering if I needed to standardise the fandom label more.

[(Anonymous)]

Found a duplicate!

Obi-Wan Kenobi/Anakin Skywalker (SW:PT), Obi-Wan Kenobi/Anakin Skywalker (SWPT)

pre-emptive strike

[(Anonymous)]

After reading the various queries threads, I can see the problem with my outstanding nom, so...

For Stargate SG-1, please replace Daniel Jackson & SG-1 team with Daniel Jackson & Jack O'Neill & Samantha Carter & Teal'c and replace the Jack O'Neill & SG-1 team request with a Char: Jack O'Neill. Thanks!

Re: pre-emptive strike

[modzilla]

Thank you very much!