Nominations Queries 1

[modzilla]

Thanks for all the nominations so far! There are a lot - it's exciting.

General notes

• FFFX does not allow Creator's Choice of Fandom, including in crossover nominations. Please remove or re-use nominations that include Creator's Choice of Fandom.


• Thank you to people who contributed thoughts about group nominations! Here's where I've landed:
  • Nominations for a group ([Character] & [Group]), such as "Lily Evans & Marauders (HP JKR)" (where "Marauders" means four characters, namely Peter Pettigrew, Sirius Black, Remus Lupin, and James Potter) means that at least two members of the group must feature prominently in the gift, and which two is up to the creator.
  • "Creator's Choice of [GROUP]" means that one member of the group must feature prominently in the gift.
  • "All: [GROUP]" means that all members of the group must feature. Please don't nominate groups of 10+ members this way.
  • I will check throughout nominations about who might appear in a particular group. If you want to speed up the approval of your nomination, please drop me a line when nominating to explain which characters are included in a group.


• You may find past tag sets helpful for formatting nominations - though note that rounds 1 & 2 used the Character slot, and rounds 3 & 4 use the Relationship slot. Sorry for not providing that before.

Specific fandom notes

Crossover Fandom
Carmilla (Carmilla)/Lucy Westenra (Dracula)
Mina Murray Harker (Dracula)/Elizabeth Lavenza (Frankenstein)
Which Dracula, please? I will approve as the Stokes novel if I don't hear back.

Char: Edward Elric (FMA:B) & Creator's Choice of Fandom
Char: Shikako Nara (DoS) & Creator's Choice of Fandom
Will Graham (Hannibal TV) & Hannibal Lecter (Hannibal TV) & Creator's Choice of Character (CCOF)
FFFX does not use Creator's Choice of Fandom. Please remove these nominations or use the slot for something else.

Charlie Weasley (HP) & Toothless (HTTYD)
Edmund Pevensie (Narnia-CS Lewis) & Tom Riddle (Harry Potter)
Sansa Stark (Game of Thrones) & Luna Lovegood (Harry Potter)
Sirius Black (Harry Potter) & Edmund Pevensie (Narnia)
Sirius Black (Harry Potter)/Wanda Maximoff (WandaVision)
Please specify which Harry Potter fandom is meant (books? movies?) Please also let me know which Narnia fandom is meant for Edmund (books?)

Peter Pevensie (Narnia) & Will Stanton (Dark is Rising)
Will Stanton (Dark is Rising)/Susan Pevensie (Narnia)
Please specify which Narnia fandom is meant (books? movies?)

Daniel Jackson (Stargate SG-1) & Atlantis (Stargate Atlantis)
Could I get more information about Atlantis as a character, please?

Ezra Bloom (Imposters) & Leverage Crew Member(s) (Leverage)
This is fine but as per recent discussion, I'll approve that as Ezra Bloom (Imposters) & Leverage Crew (Leverage) if that's okay - same with Mike Ross (Suits) & Leverage Crew Member(s) (Leverage).

Huo Wensi (Detective L) & Oth: Worldbuilding (DMBJ)
That looks OK but I'm not familiar with "DMBJ" - is this the same as the fandom label "盗墓笔记重启 | The Lost Tomb Reboot (TV)"?

Dimension 20 (Web Series)
Just checking people would rather have it nominated under the umbrella label (as it is so far) rather than specific storylines? I understand the specific storylines don't necessarily have worldbuilding in common.

Revolutionary Arc - kitsunerei88 (Fanfic Disambiguation)
This is the tag I've moved the Revolutionary Arc nominations into - apologies, they got sucked into Harry Potter when I approved that.

Shaperaverse
Could I check please what pieces of media are currently covered by this tag?

Star Trek: Deep Space Nine
Jadzia Dax & Creator’s Choice of DS9 Crew (ST: DS9)
It looks to me like this is covered by nominating Jadzia Dax as a character and by optional prompts - please help me understand if this is not the case?

Star Trek: Strange New Worlds (TV)
Una Chin-Riley & Creator’s Choice of Enterprise Crew Member(s) (ST: SNW)
It looks to me like this is covered by nominating Una Chin-Riley as a character and by optional prompts - please help me understand if this is not the case?

Comments

[event_kosch]

Shaperaverse nominator here :)
This tag covers a number of musicals, two books and a podcast written by Paul Shapera. Though the podcast is basically the same as one of the books.
There are some albums that can be standalone, even if they're in the same universe and share some characters, but for characters I'm thinking of requesting, they appear in works that aren't really standalone (either as single works or as part of smaller series of albums).

The full list as of now is
New Albion Tetralogy:
- The Dolls of New Albion
- The New Albion Radio Hour (Lloyd first appears here)
- The New Albion Guide to Analogue Consciousness
- The Room Beneath New Albion

The Ballad of Lost Hollow:
- Miss Helen's Weird West Cabaret
- Uncle Raven's Super Happy Fun Time Carnival (Raven's first appears here)
- The Path From (Lost Hollow to New Albion)
- The Grand Cyberpunk Gala of Gabriella Gadfly

- Uncle Raven's Storytime Theatre: Never Never Land
- Han Mi's Storytime Theatre: How to Talk To A Cute Girl Without Being a Creep

Adams Arc:
- Justacorp (David's first appearance)
- Shadow & Flames
- Caravan

- Astonishing Tales of Highly Improbable (podcast) + The Posthuman Playhouse (book) (only information on Matt, most information on Lloyd, Raven | David)

- Fairy Tales for the Lost and Wandering
- Lost Fables From New Albion (book)
- Fairy Tales for Homeless Faeries

The Fairypunk Triolgy:
- The Forgotten Meme
- The Broken Cyborg
- The Lost Fairy

- Helen's Hell Hags
- The Fallen
- Jill's Psychedelic Sunday

Secrets Series:
- Katy Shaw and the Search for the Stolen Secret
- Nash Harding and the Secret of the Twisted Tower
- Kevin & Abi And the Secret of the Golden Pendant
- Kevin & Abi And The Secret of Stolen Sun

- Posthuman War (6 Acts, second most information on Lloyd and Raven | David)
- And current live show - The Rescue of Jill & Marjolein

And for mostly standalone albums, there are also:
- Janissary
- A Pirate's Tale
- Slenderman the Musical
- Cthulhu: the Funksical (+ extra stories in the album)
- Lullabies
- The Yam Salve Song
- A Covid Christmas
- Subduction
- Anamnesis
- The Coffee Cellar
- The Little Mermaid
- Despedida
- The Silver Key
- The King in Yellow

[modzilla]

Thanks, that's helpful information. Could you please clarify: do you mean that the Astonishing Tales of the Highly Improbable podcast covers the Posthuman Playhouse book (or the reverse)? Would you consider the mostly-standalone albums to be supplementary canon?

I am also emailing you about another fffx topic.

[event_kosch]

The Posthuman Playhouse book is an edited version of the podcast, so it's the latter. And yeah, those albums to very much provide further context on a few settings and characters, they're just not a necessary listen and don't require context themselves.
Seen the email, getting on it ASAP.