Last Nominations Queries Before Sign-Ups

[modzilla]

Thanks for all your input so far. Thanks especially for your patience, and for a friend who lent me a hand as Modthra (normally a placeholder account) and whose help saved you from having to be even more patient. I have some more queries; I hope to open sign-ups in the next twelve hours and will extend the sign-up period to match the delay.

I'm processing the last of what's on my screen and have further questions:


Le Fantôme de l'Opéra | Phantom of the Opera & Related Fandoms
Do you have a preferred canon, please?

Game of Thrones (TV)
Oberyn Martell/Ellaria Sand & Oberyn's Daughters
Which characters do the Daughters include, please, and is this for Any or All or something else?

Hawkeye (TV 2021)
Kate Bishop & Peter Parker (Hawkeye TV)
It's not clear to me that Peter Parker appears in Hawkeye. I am happy to approve this pair in Crossover Fandom.

クロヒョウ龍が如く | Kurohyou Ryū ga Gotoku | Black Panther: Like a Dragon (Video Game)
I am merging this into 龍が如く | Ryuu ga Gotoku | Yakuza (Video Games) - I hope that's okay?

The Legend of Vox Machina (Cartoon)
Percy de Rolo III & Members of Vox Machina (TLOVM)
Who is covered by the Members, please? Could you specify?

Marvel 616
Ben Reilly & Member(s) of the God Fighters Team (616)
Who are the God Fighters team, and could you give me more information about what you were looking for here, please?

Pride and Prejudice - Jane Austen
Fitzwilliam Darcy/Original Romance Novel Rake (P&P - Austen)
I'm a little confused by this being a nomination for an original character yet one from a romance novel. Would just Original Rake do?

Star Wars Original Trilogy
Luke Skywalker & Rogue Squadron (SW:OT)
Could you specify the characters covered by Rogue Squadron, please? Did you want any or all to appear?

Star Wars: The Clone Wars (2008) - All Media Types
Coruscant Guard & Dogma (SWTCW)
I'm not sure I understand the Coruscant Guard nomination - does this group have distinct characters within it? Would "Dogma & Original Coruscant Guard Character(s)" work?

Stargate Atlantis
Vala Mal Doran/John Sheppard (SGA)
I'm happy to approve this ship under Crossover Fandom, but Vala doesn't seem to have appeared in Atlantis?

Sunless Sea
The Dapper Chap/Zee-Captain(s) (Sunless Sea)
For the Zee-Captains, could you help me understand what you're looking for with the plural, please?

Teen Wolf (TV)
Nogitsune!Stiles & Members of The Pack (TW TV)
Stiles Stilinski & Members of The Pack (TW TV)
Theo Raeken & Member(s) of the Pack (TW TV)
Could you specify what you're looking for with these pack noms please, and what characters they cover?

バチカン奇跡調査官 | Vatican Kiseki Chousakan | Vatican Miracle Examiner (Anime)
Bill Suskins & Elizabeth Maurier (VKC)
I can't seem to find Elizabeth Maurier for the anime, only the light novels. Could I get some assistance please?

Young Justice V1 (Comics)
Bart Allen & Tim Drake & Kon-El | Conner Kent & Cassie Sandsmark (Young Justice V1)
Tim Drake/Kon-El (Young Justice v1)
I'm a little confused about why this is nominated separately - is it a distinct continuity to the main DCU Comics?


Please also let me know of
-mis-spellings
-characters appearing in the wrong fandoms
-the exact same tag appearing in two fandoms, or 'wandering'
-the same character or ship appearing twice in a fandom with different formattings.

Thanks (many).

Comments

[(Anonymous)]

Oberyn's onscreen daughters are Obara, Nym, and Tyene. They have five offscreen sisters. One is named Elia. The other four are mentioned but never named or shown onscreen. In the books, their names are Sarella, Obella, Dorea, and Loreza. I am definitely going for Any, not All. The idea of All in this context is sort of terrifying.

[(Anonymous)]

Oh, and all of them have the last name Sand, not Martell. In case it matters!

[modzilla]

Thanks. So:

Oberyn Martell/Ellaria Sand & Daughters [Any: Obara Nym Tyene Elia Others]

?

[extrapenguin]

Not the nominator, but the Coruscant Guard is a group with several distinct named characters in it: Fox, Thorn, Stone, Thire, and Hound, in addition to a number of unnamed characters. Dogma is not a member.

[modzilla]

Thanks. I'll hope to hear back from the nominator as well.

[(Anonymous)]

Duplicate:

僕のヒーローアカデミア | Boku no Hero Academia | My Hero Academia
Aizawa Shouta | Eraserhead & Shinsou Hitoshi (BNHA)
Aizawa Shouta | Eraserhead & Shinsou Hitoshi

[(Anonymous)]

And a couple more:

Bleach

Grimmjow Jaegerjaques/Kurosaki Ichigo (Bleach)
Grimmjow Jaegerjaques/Kurosaki Ichigo

Kurosaki Ichigo/Sado "Chad" Yasutora (Bleach)
Kurosaki Ichigo/Sado "Chad" Yasutora

[reshiel]

Hello! Not the nominator of either, but 全职高手 | The King's Avatar (novel) currently under Uncategorized Fandoms is the same as 全职高手 - 蝴蝶蓝 | Quánzhí Gāoshǒu - Húdié Lán under Books & Literature.

These characters/relationships currently under The King's Avatar (novel) are also already in QZGS:

• Char: Su Mucheng (King's Avatar Novel)
- the same as Char: Su Mucheng (QZGS)

• Char: Xu Boyuan (King's Avatar Novel)
- the same as Char: Xu Boyuan | Blue River (QZGS)

• Ye Xiu & Xu Boyuan (King's Avatar Novel)
- the same as Blue River & Ye Xiu (QZGS), unless the nominator wanted to distinguish the game avatar from the player

[shadaras]

As one of the Quanzhi Gaoshou nominators (the one who did all the Char: [X] noms in QZGS - HL), I'd love to have those TKA (novel) noms blended into the (canonical) tag 全职高手 - 蝴蝶蓝 | Quánzhí Gāoshǒu - Húdié Lán!

(I can't say if the Blue River & Ye Xiu (QZGS) nominator wanted to specify game avatar or not, but tbh I'd assume it's referring to the player, since that's the common use in the canon/fandom... but I'd be fine with having both nominations in the tagset, in case someone did specifically want Blue River-the-avatar & Ye Xiu!)

[modzilla]

Thanks both! I'll take The King's Avatar (novel) out, though I'm happy to add the game-avatar-distinguishing relationship back if the nominator asks for it.

[primeideal]

Minor typo in Wheel of Time - TV:
Moiraine Damodred & La'an Mandragoran -- this should be "Lan" (or "al'Lan").

[modzilla]

Thanks - fixed!

SGA nom

[blueyeti]

Sorry about the Vala/John nom. Fanon ate my brain and I forgot Vala didn't have any crossover episodes.

I'd appreciate it as a crossover nom, thank you.

Re: SGA nom

[(Anonymous)]

There is a crossover episode with the two of them, but it's in SG-1 not Atlantis. IDK if that'd work for you?

[razia]

Duplicate!

Mass Effect: Andromeda
Char: Alec Ryder (Mass Effect: Andromeda)
Char: Alec Ryder (ME:A)

[modzilla]

Thanks!

[(Anonymous)]

Fast & Furious (movies) has a duplicate:

Brian O'Conner/Dominic Toretto ((Fast & Furious))
Brian O'Conner/Dominic Toretto (Fast & Furious)

[modzilla]

Thanks!

[(Anonymous)]

So, I was hoping you'd at least query this instead of outright rejecting, but could you tell me why you didn't feel Hogwarts (Castle) [HP] was not a suitable nomination? I think most of the fandom would agree me that it's at least partially sentient...

[modzilla]

I'm sorry for disappointing you. I'd prefer to stick with canonical characters. Would you like to substitute something else?

Hawkeye

[(Anonymous)]

Hi! About the Hawkeye nominations, it’s true that Peter Parker doesn’t appear in the series. I’m sorry, I just didn’t think of adding it as Crossover Fandom.

Re: Hawkeye

[modzilla]

Thanks! It's in there now, anyway :)

[violet_pencil]

The members of Vox Machina (in the cartoon canon) are Vex'ahlia, Vax'ildan, Keyleth, Grog, Pike, Scanlan and Percy de Rolo III.

[modzilla]

Thanks, that's helpful!

[(Anonymous)]

For the P&P, Original Rake is totally fine and less cumbersome! I think I was thinking "a rake, the sort of character archetype from romance novels", unnecessarily.

Thanks for your hard work!

[modzilla]

No worries, I was probably also overthinking it. It's there now, thanks!

[withthekeyisking]

Hello!

Ben Reilly & Member(s) of the God Fighters Team (616)
In the 2020 Iron Man run, Tony assembles a team to go fight a big bad in space. Ben Reilly is part of that team. On the way to the big bad, the groups tosses around possible names for themselves, and settle on the God Fighters. The team is Ben, Iron Man, War Machine, Hellcat, Frog-Man, Gargoyle, Misty Knight, and Halcyon.

Nogitsune!Stiles & Members of The Pack (TW TV), Stiles Stilinski & Members of The Pack (TW TV), Theo Raeken & Member(s) of the Pack (TW TV)
This is more of a gray area group, because there are people who join the pack and leave it over the course of the show, so there isn't really one definitive pack (because at one point it's A, B, C, and another time it's B, C, D, etc.). So what I was looking for here was basically just interactions between Nogitusne!Stiles, Stiles, and Theo with the pack members, but did not have a set time period in mind for which specific pack members I want to see them with. I am seriously open to allllll the members of the pack, and will have prompts in my letter that involve basically all of them for my giftor.

[modzilla]

Thanks. I'll tweak the first label and approve.

For the Nogitsune label, I'm sorry, this level of flexibility runs counter to what I think a tag needs to do - which is to establish a point of reference between the requester and the offerer. I think that might work for your letter but not necessarily for anyone else who wanted to offer and request it. I'm happy to approve Char: Nogitsune!Stiles (and other Char noms) and honor a DNW such as "DNW: character study with no other character interactions."

Re: Vatican nom

[(Anonymous)]

Hi!

For Vatican Miracle Examiner, the fandom as a whole has been using the anime tag to publish fic for the novel characters, as there is no official translation and so not enough people writing to merit a novel tag.

In a past Yuletide (2020?), we received an 'all media types' category, but as far as I know it's yet to become a canonical tag. Personally, I wouldn't mind keeping Elizabeth under the 'anime' category.

- VME nominator

Re: Vatican nom

[modzilla]

Sorry, I would really prefer not to approve a character under a canon label where they don't appear. If you are the nominator of all the other VME characters and relationships, I could change it to a label that includes the light novels? Or I will approve the Elizabeth relationship under a light novels label.

[(Anonymous)]

Hi!

For Star Wars OT, can I adjust to Luke & Any Member(s) of Rogue Squadron?

Thank you!

[modzilla]

Could you clarify who that covers, please?

[silveredeye]

Hello.

The Dapper Chap/Zee-Captain(s) (Sunless Sea) – most (all?) of the ships involving the Zee-Captain(s) are canonized this way. Zee-Captain is the player character who generally does not have a very good life expectancy. A named NPC may successively encounter a lot of PCs, all of whom are (different) Zee-Captains.

So basically I'm fine with both "the Dapper Chap and one particular Zee-Captain" and "the Dapper Chap and any number of Zee-Captains he meets and romances as previous ones are lost at sea". I hope that clarifies.

[modzilla]

Thanks for coming back to explain more! That makes sense, though it still seems to me to better work as a tag on a fanwork than a tag in a prompt. However, it also sounds like anyone else offering or requesting it would have the same understanding as you, which is what matters most.

Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries Tags

[(Anonymous)]

There's some duplication in the Miss Fisher fandom. Three versions of the fandom tag used at the end of relationships, and Phryne Fisher/Jack Robinson appears under two of them.

Phryne Fisher/Jack Robinson (MFMM TV)
Phryne Fisher/Jack Robinson (MFMM)

The third variant is "(Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries (TV))"

Re: Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries Tags

[modzilla]

Thanks! I won't standardise the disambiguation tags at this point, but I'll delete the duplicate.