Nominations Queries 4

[modzilla]

We're nearly up to sign-ups! I just have a few more things to clear up (as well as further errors you find in the tag set - I'd like to know about them, even as I gradually make my way through those identified already).

When sign-ups open, I'll make further nominations slots available, but that requires wiping the record of what each individual person nominated, so if you want to keep a record of that, please do that in the next day.

On to queries!

B-Movie Series - Alan Spencer
Andy Ryerson/Creator's Choice of B-Movie Monster (B-Movie Series)
Could I get a bit more information about who is covered by the B-Movie Monsters, please? (Also, sorry, nominator - I think I had questions about all of the Alan Spencer books, so please read further in the post.)


Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon (Anime 1992) & Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime & Manga)
Nominators, could I hear your thoughts on merging or splitting these please?


Common Law (TV)
Travis Marks & Wes Mitchell & Therapy Group (Common Law)
Could I confirm who is covered by the therapy group, please?


Critical Role (Web Series)
There's an ongoing discussion about splitting this by storyline/campaign or keeping it as a multi-storyline umbrella. If you nominated for this fandom or might offer or request it, I'd be interested to hear your thoughts.


Crossover Fandom
James Copley (The Old Guard)/Scott Summers (X-Men Movieverse)
Thanks for specifying Movieverse for X-Men. Did you also want movieverse for The Old Guard, or comics? Thanks!


The Gilded Age (TV 2022)
Group: The van Rhijn family (TGA)
Who does this cover, please? Agnes van Rhijn & Agnes' husband & Oscar van Rhijn, or are more people included?


Kamen Rider Kuuga
Godai Yuusuke & Minori Yuuske (Kuuga)
Is Minori Yuuske meant to be Godai Minori? Or someone else?


The Lord of the Rings - J. R. R. Tolkien & The Silmarillion and other histories of Middle-Earth - J. R. R. Tolkien
Under Lord of the Rings, the characters Mithrellas and Imrazor are nominated; under the Silmarillion, Elmo is nominated. The impression I get is that these characters appear in Unfinished Tales. Is that correct? If so, I'd prefer to sort Unfinished Tales categories into one or the other category - not both - or potentially Crossover Fandom. Would appreciate advice here.


Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries (TV)
Phryne Fisher & Creator's Choice of The Wardlow Family (Miss Fisher's Murder Mysteries (TV))
I'd appreciate further guidance on who is part of the Wardlow Family, please.


Original Work
Female SFF YA Protagonist/Female BFF/Male Love Interest (F/F/M) (OW)
Is this a literal YA protagonist who becomes aware that she is in a book, or were you aiming to suggest a particular cluster of genre expectations (and if so could I hear a little bit more about that please?)

Otome Game Princely Male Lead/His Awkward Villainous Nemesis Trying to Go By the Script (M/M)
To check I understand this - the villainous nemesis is aware he's in a game and the male lead isn't?

Used Up Human Cauldron/Upright Cultivator (OW)
I'm not sure I understand what's meant by the used up human cauldron - please unpack that a little?


The Roaches Have No King - Daniel Evan Weiss
Char: Original Blattella germanica Character (The Roaches Have No King)
Hector Tambellini & Creator's Choice of Periplaneta americana (The Roaches Have No King)
Sorry, I'm having trouble finding information on characters - or potential characters - here. Could I get more information about this, please?


Savage Island: A Dinosaur Thriller - Alan Spencer
Dr. Prater/Creator's Choice of Patient(s) (Savage Island: A Dinosaur Thriller)
Could I get a bit more information about the patients, please?


SEAL Team (TV)
Could I check who is covered by the Bravo Team Ensemble please?


Space Sharks - Alan Spencer
Dr. Dean Fleming/Pathfinder 3000 (Space Sharks)
We're having trouble finding the Pathfinder (ironically). Is this the being referred to in a review as "the robot cyborg thing that was activated to lead a group of survivors to the escape pods"?


Stargate Atlantis
Sam Carter & ALL: John Sheppard’s Team (SGA)
Who is covered by the team, please? For example, does this include Aiden Ford?


Tintin - All Media Types
Could you please pick a media type, or help me understand why All Media Types is ideal?


Tortall - Tamora Pierce
Dovasary Balitang & Jasson II of Conté (Tortall)
Could I check please that "II' is the correct designation for the character you had in mind? That's fine if so, but it looks as though Jasson II is several generations removed from the character who is contemporary with Dovasary, so I wanted to ask.


Ultraman Mebius
It looks as though Ultraman X and Ultraman Zero don't appear in this show - help me find them or let me know what you meant?


バチカン奇跡調査官 | Vatican Kiseki Chousakan | Vatican Miracle Examiner (Anime)
I'm having trouble finding the character Ajmer Chandra Singh (VKC) - could I get some help with that please?


X-Men (Comicverse)
I may be misunderstanding, sorry, but this seems quite broad and as though it overlaps with other comics categories I've approved. Could you help me understand what this covers, please?


游园惊梦 - 夏达 (Manhua)
Char: Vengeful Concubine (YYJM)
General/Fish Maiden (YYJM)
Rabbit Maiden/Prince (YYJM)
I'm having trouble finding information about this in English - could you please let me know a bit more about what this is and about the characters?

Nominations Queries 5 + warning of nominations clearing

[modzilla]

Nominators, please help me with the last few queries before we can open sign-ups!

B-Movie Series - Alan Spencer
Andy Ryerson/Creator's Choice of B-Movie Monster (B-Movie Series)
Could I get a bit more information about who is covered by the B-Movie Monsters, please? (Also, sorry, nominator - I think I had questions about all of the Alan Spencer books, so please read further in the post.)
If I do not hear back before opening sign-ups, I'll approve Andy Ryerson as a character; you are welcome to discuss it with me further.


Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon (Anime 1992) & Bishoujo Senshi Sailor Moon | Pretty Guardian Sailor Moon (Anime & Manga)
Nominators, could I hear your thoughts on merging or splitting these please?
If I do not hear back before opening sign-ups, I will approve the 1992 anime.
1992 nom
Kunzite/Zoisite (Sailor Moon 1992)

Anime & Manga noms
Chiba Mamoru/Helios/Shitennou (Sailor Moon)
Chiba Mamoru/Kunzite (PGSM)
Chiba Mamoru/Shitennou & Helios (PGSM)
Hino Rei/Jadeite (PGSM)
Senshi/Shitennou (PGSM)


Common Law (TV)
Travis Marks & Wes Mitchell & Therapy Group (Common Law)
Could I confirm who is covered by the therapy group, please?
I understand this is a distinct group, so if I do not hear back before opening sign-ups, I will approve this, but I'd really appreciate confirmation of what characters are in this group to help me moderate it if a question comes up later.


Original Work
Female SFF YA Protagonist/Female BFF/Male Love Interest (F/F/M) (OW)
Is this a literal YA protagonist who becomes aware that she is in a book, or were you aiming to suggest a particular cluster of genre expectations (and if so could I hear a little bit more about that please?)
If I do not hear back before opening sign-ups, I will reject this, but am open to discussing it further.

Otome Game Princely Male Lead/His Awkward Villainous Nemesis Trying to Go By the Script (M/M)
To check I understand this - the villainous nemesis is aware he's in a game and the male lead isn't?

Used Up Human Cauldron/Upright Cultivator (OW)
I understand this is based on cultivation tropes, but would appreciate if the first term especially could be expanded (or if others could chime in to confirm this already makes perfect sense, that would also be fine) at previous thread.
If I don't hear back before sign-ups open, I will approve this, but I'd really like to hear from others about how clear this trope-shorthand is to them.


Savage Island: A Dinosaur Thriller - Alan Spencer
Dr. Prater/Creator's Choice of Patient(s) (Savage Island: A Dinosaur Thriller)
Could I get a bit more information about the patients, please?
If I don't hear back before opening sign-ups, I'll approve as Dr Prater, but am open to further discussion.


Space Sharks - Alan Spencer
Dr. Dean Fleming/Pathfinder 3000 (Space Sharks)
We're having trouble finding the Pathfinder (ironically). Is this the being referred to in a review as "the robot cyborg thing that was activated to lead a group of survivors to the escape pods"?
If I don't hear back before opening sign-ups, I will approve as Dr Fleming, but am open to further discussion.


Tintin - All Media Types
Could you please pick a media type, or help me understand why All Media Types is ideal?
If I don't hear back from you before sign-ups, I will approve as Comics.


Tortall - Tamora Pierce
Dovasary Balitang & Jasson II of Conté (Tortall)
Could I check please that "II' is the correct designation for the character you had in mind? A Jasson III and a later Jasson appear in the books, but I can't find a Jasson II. Their historical existence is implied by the appearance of Jasson III, but I'm not willing to approve a "Jasson II" about which nothing seems to be known than "was probably a past ruler at an unknown time".
I will approve this as "Dovasary Balitang & Jasson of Conté" if I don't hear back before sign-ups.


X-Men (Comicverse)
I may be misunderstanding, sorry, but this seems quite broad and as though it overlaps with other comics categories I've approved. Could you help me understand what this covers, please?
I'm sorry, I will reject this if I don't hear back before sign-ups, but I'm open to further discussion.


游园惊梦 - 夏达 (Manhua)
Char: Vengeful Concubine (YYJM)
General/Fish Maiden (YYJM)
Rabbit Maiden/Prince (YYJM)
I'm having trouble finding information about this in English - could you please let me know a bit more about what this is and about the characters?
I'm sorry, I will reject this if I don't hear back before sign-ups, but I'm very open to re-adding it if I can learn a bit more about it.

Reminder and warning

In order to re-open nominations during sign-ups, I need to clear the record of people's individual nominations. Anything previously approved will stay in the tag set, but the record of what you personally nominated will be wiped. Please save a record if this is information that matters to you. Thanks!