modzilla: Godzilla with a clipboard (Default)
modzilla ([personal profile] modzilla) wrote in [community profile] fffx2022-07-25 11:32 pm

Nominations Queries 1

Thanks for your nominations! I have a few queries and notes:

Crossover Fandom
Caroline Bingley (Pride and Prejudice)/Blanche Ingram (Jane Eyre)
Elizabeth Elliot (Persuasion)/Caroline Bingley (Pride and Prejudice)
Jack Harkness/Will Stanton
Please be specific about which piece of media you mean for each character.

Creator's Choice of Fandom
Sorry, fffx does not include Creator's Choice of Fandom.

DCU (Comics)
Batfamily Members & Dick Grayson (DC Comics)
Please give me more information about what you would like here. Is this meant to be all or any? Who is on this list?

Dick Grayson/Creator’s Choice of Morally Ambiguous Older Man (DC Comics)
I am willing to discuss "Any [member of extremely distinct group]" on a case by case basis; however, the likelier it is that this will require a judgment call from me about whether a request has been fulfilled, the less likely I am to approve it. You can request and offer ten relationship tags per fandom, and you can repeat fandoms in your offers and requests, so please be specific when nominating - thank you!

Divergent - All Media Types
Pick a canon, please.

Les Misérables - All Media Types
Pick a canon, please.

I have Pocket Monsters | Pokemon (Main Video Game Series) with Buck/Mira and I also have Pocket Monsters: X & Y | Pokemon X & Y Versions. Could I get people's thoughts on splitting/merging, please?

Supernatural (TV 2005)
The Special Children & Sam Winchester (SPN 2005)
Are the Special Children a distinct group? Could you tell me a little more about them, please?

Yudah Cohen Series - Rebecca Fraimow
Kao/Pete (Kiss: The Series)
This tag seems like autocorrect mischief - please edit it to the relationship you want instead?

Pokemon

(Anonymous) 2022-07-25 11:53 am (UTC)(link)
Merging X&Y Version with Main Video Game Series would be my preference as someone who nominates for Pokemon in exchanges. While X&Y is a distinct subunit of the main series, all of the main series games are set in the same world and characters from one game can sometimes be met in another, with the same characterization and personality. Additionally, as someone who nominates ships for characters whose main appearance is in different games, having to make a crossover for characters who canonically exist in the same universe is counterintuitive.
zappobrien: (Default)

Re: Pokemon

[personal profile] zappobrien 2022-07-25 12:35 pm (UTC)(link)
As a Pokemon writer, and the one who nommed BuckMira, I agree with this!
jonphaedrus: (Default)

Re: Pokemon

[personal profile] jonphaedrus 2022-07-25 05:09 pm (UTC)(link)
as the person who nommed x&y, i also agree with having them merged in!