Nominations Queries 3

[modzilla]

I continue to have questions! Thanks for your answers.

Blake's 7
Any Mutoid & Any Mutoid(s) (B7)
Could I get a bit more information about what's desired here, please?

Buffy the Vampire Slayer (TV)
I've had a request to approve this as a combined Buffyverse including Angel. Opinions?

Company - Sondheim/Furth
Robert & Company (Company)
Could I get more information about what you wanted, please, nominator? Ie, is this for all of the characters covered by 'company' or any?

Crossover Fandom
Edmund Pevensie/Tom Riddle
Nominator, could you please specify fandoms?

Jean-Luc Picard (ST:TNG) & Obi-Wan Kenobi (SW)
Nominator, which part of Star Wars did you want, please?

Dragon Age (Video Games) & Dragon Age II
Am I OK to merge these into the first label or would you prefer them separated out?

The Eagle | The Eagle of the Ninth (2011)
Woman with necklace/Woman with dangling earrings at the gladiator games (The Eagle)
Could I get a bit more information about these characters, please?

Le Fantôme de l'Opéra | Phantom of the Opera & Related Fandoms
Do you have a preferred canon, please?

Fire Emblem: Fuukasetsugetsu | Fire Emblem: Three Houses and Fire Emblem Musou: Fuukasetsugetsu | Fire Emblem Warriors: Three Hopes
I am approving these separately and have moved the Linhardt/Shez nomination to Three Hopes. I think there are some unapproved noms under Three Houses that I need to approve in Three Hopes - could the nominator for the following please confirm?
Claude von Riegan/Shahid (FE3H)
Erwin Fritz Gloucester/Lorenz Hellman Gloucester (FE3H)
Lorenz Hellman Gloucester/Claude von Riegan (FE3H)
Lorenz Hellman Gloucester/Claude von Riegan/Shahid (FE3H)
Lorenz Hellman Gloucester/Shahid (FE3H)

Hades (Video Game 2018)
Char: Apollo (Hades Video Game)
Could I get more information about this character, please? They seem to be a fan character added through an unofficial mod - is that correct?

Hogan's Heroes (TV 1965)
James Kinchloe & Any Canonical Allied POW (Hogan's Heroes)
Could you give me more information about this or narrow it down, please?

Pocket Monsters | Pokemon - All Media Types
I'm approving the Main Video Game series, and am happy to approve other parts of the franchise - where would you like your nominations for this to go?

Scholomance - Naomi Novik
Please nominate a character, relationship, or worldbuilding tag under this, so that it's possible to match on it.

Star Wars: The Book of Boba Fett (TV)
Boba Fett & Tusken Characters (SW Boba Fett TV)
Could I get more information about what you wanted from this nomination, please?

Suicide Squad (Movies 2016 2021)
Rick Flag & Creator's Choice of Squad Members 2016-2021
Please be more specific. I'm also happy to approve Rick Flag on his own.

Top Gun: Maverick (2020) & Top Gun Movies
Can I approve these as the latter, or would you rather keep the 1986 and 2020 movie separate? (Also I'm sure there's a reason but I'm slightly confused by this being labelled 2020 rather than 2022 - enlighten me please?)


General
If possible, please use the existing disambiguation style when adding tags to a fandom that's already been approved. For new fandoms, you're welcome to select canonical relationships, even if those have no disambiguation information. However, crossover nominations must specify a fandom for each character.

I will approve broad "Any of X group" or "Creator's choice of X" tags only on a limited basis, and it needs to be a small and clearly defined group for me to consider it. Thanks.

Comments

[alexseanchai]

not nominator and also entirely unaware of any fan modding: Apollo is mentioned at least once in the game, see the codex entry section of the page on Thanatos on the Hades fandom wiki. so super minor canon character, but canon character nonetheless.

[westiereads]

Not nominator,but the Edmund Pevensie/Tom Riddle is Narnia and Harry Potter respectively.

[modzilla]

Useful information, thanks! Now I wonder if the nominator meant that or the version added by mods, but it does seem easier to include them.

[modzilla]

Thanks, yes. :) I need to know if the Narnian nom is books or movies, and if Tom Riddle is main Harry Potter books, Cursed Child, etc.

[ashling]

Israel Hands/Roach (Our Flag Means Death wandered into Black Sails. I guess the pirates wanna make friends with other pirates! 😂

[muccamukk]

I nominated Top Gun (Movies), since I have a mix of pairings from both and wanted to economise, but if others have really strong feelings about them being separate, I'm happy for them to be split.

The reason it's listed as 2020 is that was the original release date, and some people wrote fic based on the trailer, so AO3 made it 2020, then the pandemic delayed the release.

[(Anonymous)]

I nominated since Buffy pairings. Totally cool with Buffy the Vampire Slayer rolling into the Buffyverse to include the Angel series.

[(Anonymous)]

Stupid auto-correct. That was supposed to say "I nominated some* Buffy pairings."

[withthekeyisking]

I'm good with Angel and BTVS being put together as Buffyverse!

[(Anonymous)]

Jean-Luc Picard (ST:TNG) & Obi-Wan Kenobi (SW)

Nominator here. I wasn't set on a particular time period but if it helps disambiguate things, I'd go with the Prequel Trilogy as I was going for "two famous diplomats from the star franchises" thing.

[chase_acow]

I've been reading almost every day and I never noticed it was 2020! Good thing I'm not a detective.

I intend to offer/request, and I'd also be fine with Top Gun (Movies) for ease combining wanted pairings!

[muccamukk]

Some people, myself included, have been tagging it as TG:M 2022, and the whole thing is synned together in one big lump now anyway. I only noticed it was 2020 because that was what it autofilled as when I posted fic.

*high five* anyway. Maybe we'll end up writing for each other!

[flowersforgraves]

Hogan's Heroes nominator. I'm looking for that character in combination with any of the canonical POWs without listing all of them -- there are perhaps six or seven named characters who fit that description. I'm happy to narrow it down further (to "& Any Resident of Barracks 2" -- which narrows it down from about 7 to 5) if that would be helpful.

[(Anonymous)]

You approved Creator's Choice of Squad Members last year. :( The intended prompt is literally "Rick Flag and any member of the squad from either of the movies that you want, I would love to be surprised."

[(Anonymous)]

Same here!

[fleetsparrow]

Company nominator here: I actually think I meant Robert & Couples, because listing all of the couples would take up too much tag space, and just spaced and wrote "Company" twice, whoops. I was thinking similar to how the show is, with series of vignettes between Robert and the couples, but I'm good with either changing it or dropping it altogether.

[modzilla]

Oops! Thanks - fixed now.

[modzilla]

Thanks, especially for the extra info. I've had one request via PM to keep them separate so I'll hold on that just for now.

[modzilla]

Thanks!

[modzilla]

Prequel would be great, thanks!

[modzilla]

Okay. 5-7 sounds like it fits my criteria for this year of small and distinct. Whichever of the two you go with, could you reply listing out all the characters that covers, please?

[modzilla]

Okay - fair enough, I misremembered and I apologize. I wasn't expecting what feels like a bit of an explosion of Creator's Choice nominations this year, but it isn't particularly fair of me to suggest a nomination one year then take it away the next.

As a compromise, I'll approve it, but could you please confirm the full list of characters that covers so I am confident when it comes to checking works?

[modzilla]

Hm - are you able to narrow that down a bit more, please? I may be misunderstanding you, but it sounds like you want "Robert and the entire rest of the cast" and I would prefer not to approve a nomination that's simply "Everyone" if it's too many people to fit into a list.

Good luck with your make-up work!

[flowersforgraves]

Sure -- "& Any Resident of Barracks 2" covers the following canonical named characters:
- Robert Hogan
- Andrew Carter
- Louis Lebeau
- Peter Newkirk
- Richard Baker

[shadaras]

Hi, a heads-up for one of my nominations!



Revolutionary Arc - Kitsunerei88 is a Harry Potter fanfic, and therefore the fandom name got synned to "Harry Potter - J. K. Rowling". (statement of being open to recursive fanworks)

You'll need to add a new fandom (probably "Revolutionary Arc - Kitsunerei88 (DFE)" or the like) and re-associate the nominations. To make that easier (like, if you wanted to use batch load), here are the nominations again:

Oth: Worldbuilding (Rev Arc), Mei Ling Song/Baird Queenscove (Rev Arc), Solo: Hermione Granger (Rev Arc), John Kowalski & Francesca Lam (Rev Arc), Francesca Lam/Aldon Rosier (Rev Arc)

Sorry for the trouble! Thanks for all your hard work!

[(Anonymous)]

"Clark Kent/Lex Luthor (Smallville)" has wandered into DCU Comics!

[modzilla]

Yes, I see it, thanks. Please check in future before nominating whether the fandom label has already been synned. I understand it's a bit of an arms race.

[(Anonymous)]

I went ahead and pulled it for now, because I didn't want to end up causing extra work for you. I'm trying to think of a better way to put it, it's just hard with a largeish group of characters. /o\

[erlkonig_gheyn]

Hello! I nominated char: Apollo in Hades. I don't believe he appears in the game, so technically he's an OC, but he's one that could be implied to exist. It's Greek god themed, and Artemis is there. I'd love to see a work that carves out Apollo's role in Hades. . . sort of imagine how he interacts with the other characters, or if Zagreus meets him in the work, how that would go. Basically like, what he would be like if he were there.

I did not know there was a modded version that included him lol!

Thanks alexseanchai for finding a reference to him! Yes, I think I'm going for more this super-minor canon character whose existence is mostly implied through the context of the game being about Greek gods.

Scholomance was me too. Sorry, I left my list unfinished. I'm still deciding on the ships to nominate. I'll update it soon!

[kanna_ophelia]

Hi,

The Blake's 7 Mutoids were nominated on my behalf. They are characters who have been punished by being repeatedly mind wiped, technologically modified and made dependent on blood serum, so they don't actually have individual names.

[(Anonymous)]

Selfcorrection: I'd forgotten that wd do learn the name of one prior to her wiping (Keera). If it's easier, I could nominate just Keera--I don't have any preference as to WHICH vampire robot girl really ;)

https://blakes7.fandom.com/wiki/Keera

[(Anonymous)]

Not the Dragon Age II nominator, but a different Dragon Age nominator: They should all be together, they're a single continuity with many overlapping characters.

[(Anonymous)]

Hi, I also nominated Top Gun (Movies) and was hoping to keep them together so I wouldn't have to ask for two fandoms when the new movie is a sequel with a consistent and clear through-line and connection to the original.

[modzilla]

If you can list the list of applicable characters, I'm still open to approving it!

[modzilla]

I understand that's now been fixed thanks to wranglers. Thanks!

[modzilla]

Thanks for the explanation. I'm sorry, I would prefer only to approve characters who appear in their canons.

[modzilla]

That would be great, thanks.

[modzilla]

Thank you!